Pesticide active substance and MRL application procedures

How to submit a dossier for scientific evaluation

At EFSA we peer review the risk assessment A specialised field of applied science that involves reviewing scientific data and studies in order to evaluate risks associated with certain hazards. It involves four steps: hazard identification, hazard characterisation, exposure assessment and risk characterisation of active substances used in plant protection products (i.e. pesticides) before they can be placed on the EU market or before the renewal of a currently approved substance. We are also responsible for the assessment of maximum residue levels (MRLs) which refer to the highest level of a pesticide Substance used to kill or control pests, including disease-carrying organisms and undesirable insects, animals and plants residue that is legally tolerated in or on food or feed when pesticides are applied correctly.

The administrative and scientific requirements of your application differ depending which procedure you need to apply for. In short, the workflows are different for the approval of new active substances and amendment of approval conditions, renewal of approved active substances, for the setting or changing of MRLs, and for basic substances.

Below you can follow our step-by-step guide to the application process. It includes five main phases: pre-submission, submission and admissibility check, risk assessment by a EU Member State and EFSA’s evaluation, and post-adoption.

For basic substances the procedure is simpler and includes: pre-submission, submission and completeness check, risk assessment and post-adoption.

You need to use different documents and tools during each phase to move the process forward.

Useful overview of the application process

New active substances

For the review of active substances, you have to submit an application dossier through a national contact point. One of the Member States is appointed as “Rapporteur” (RMS) and carries out an initial risk assessment and prepares the Draft Assessment Report (DAR), which is peer reviewed by EFSA together with the Member States.

Application procedure – New active substances and amendment of approval conditions

To help you understand the process, this diagram gives you an overview and indicate the tools you need to use at each stage. Each step is essential to move your application forward.

Check the diagram (PDF)

Re-evaluation of active substances

Active substances that have already been approved are re-evaluated before their expiry date under the renewal programme (“AIR”). One of the Member States is appointed as “Rapporteur” (RMS) and carries out an initial risk assessment and prepares the Renewal Assessment Report (RAR), together with another Member State that is appointed as Co-rapporteur (Co-RMS). The RAR is then peer reviewed by EFSA together with the Member States.  

Application procedure – Renewal of approval of pesticide active substances

To help you understand the process, this diagram gives you an overview and indicate the tools you need to use at each stage. Each step is essential to move your application forward.

Check the diagram (PDF)

Maximum Residue Levels

Applications for setting or changing maximum residue levels (MRLs) can be submitted at any time through a national contact point. One of the EU Member States (Evaluating Member State – EMS) carries out an initial risk assessment and prepares an Evaluation Report (ER) that EFSA later reviews. 

Application procedure – Maximum Residue Levels for pesticides

To help you understand the process, this diagram gives you an overview and indicate the tools you need to use at each stage. Each step is essential to move your application forward.

Check the diagram (PDF)

Basic substances

Active substances that are not predominantly used as plant protection products but can be of value for plant protection are called basic substances.  

Some information below may be not applicable to basic substances. You can find further information on the approval of basic substances and the applicable procedure on the European Commission website and in the Working document on the procedure for application of basic substances. The application dossier for a basic substance needs to be prepared in IUCLID format. For details you can consult the basic substance application manual

Application procedure – Basic Substances

To help you understand the process, this diagram gives you an overview and indicate the tools you need to use at each stage. Each step is essential to move your application forward.

Check the diagram (PDF)

For any question on the preparation of your application, we strongly recommend requesting pre-submission advice to EFSA to clarify any doubts you may have regarding the requirements and content of your future application. This can be done using the Connect.EFSA portal, upon registration.

Getting started

EU legislation explains the overall process, the steps in the authorisation procedure, and subsequent marketing of the product.

Legislation

  • Regulation EC 1107/2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market including basic substances
  • Regulation EU 2020/1740 on the provisions for the implementation of the renewal procedure for active substances (repealing Regulation EU 844/2012)
  • Regulation EU 284/2013 on data requirements for active substances, in accordance with Regulation EC 1107/2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market
  • Regulation EU 2021/428 adopting standard data formats for the submission of applications for the approval or the amendment to the conditions of approval of active substances
  • Regulation EU 546/2011 implementing Regulation EC 1107/2009 as regards uniform principles for evaluation and authorisation of plant protection products

For Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs) you should check:

  • Regulation EC 396/2005 on maximum residue levels of pesticides in or on food and feed of plant and animal origin

It is also relevant to check the EC overview on the authorisation process. For any question on the authorisation and the legislation, please contact the sante-consult-e4 [at] ec.europa.eu (European Commission).

Please be aware that we are required by law to make the non-confidential version of your application publicly available in the course of the application process and to hold a public consultation. Consult this page for information on how to request confidentiality for specific information in your application.

Administrative guidance

EFSA’s administrative guidance documents describe in detail all the phases of the application life-cycle, from pre-submission to the conclusion of the evaluation. They specify the administrative requirements for preparing and submitting an application and provide practical tips and tools to support this process.

N.B. We regularly update our administrative guidance documents to take account of new working practices. Please check that you use the latest version of these documents before applying!

Scientific guidance documents tell you what scientific data and other information you need to include in your plant protection product application dossier.

Scientific guidance

An application dossier needs to contain information on the active substance under approval and on the formulated product for which the authorisation will be sought.

When preparing a dossier, you should consult the Commission’s database, which contains guidance documents, test methods and supporting documents relevant for the risk assessment processes for the (renewal) of approvals of chemical and microbiological active substances and for authorisations of chemical and microbiological plant protection products.

  • EC guidance document database on Active substances (European Commission’s Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed – phytopharmaceuticals)

Revised scientific criteria for the determination of endocrine disrupting properties (ED) were introduced by Regulation EU 2018/605. As a consequence, all dossiers and assessment reports (DAR/RAR) must include an assessment of the substance’s ED properties. EFSA carries out an assessment to decide whether the ED criteria are met. You can read the ED procedure for new active substances here. The procedure for renewals is outlined in Regulation EU 2018/1659.

The overview of ED assessment of pesticide active substances is provided in a dedicated report, which is regularly updated and published on our website.

There are many additional resources that are relevant when preparing the scientific information to include in an active substance approval or renewal of approval dossier:

For maximum residue levels you should check:

  • EC guidance documents on MRLs (European Commission’s Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed - phytopharmaceuticals)

N.B. We sometimes update our scientific guidance documents to take account of new science, tools and working practices. Please check that you use the latest version of these documents before applying!

We strive for a customer-oriented approach and provide a range of support services, which are available to you throughout the application process – from pre-submission to post-adoption:

  • Services to applicants – from pre-submission advice and responses to queries and clarification teleconferences at various stages of the application process.
  • SME support services – in addition to the services for all applicants, we offer a range of services dedicated to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) preparing and submitting applications, including fast-tracking of queries and support for using IT tools.
  • Frequently Asked Questions – to clarify any doubts about the applicable procedure.

1. Pre-submission

What do I need to do first? Register in our systems, request advice and notify studies.

You need to register on our platform to access our support and start getting ready to submit your application.

  • Connect.EFSA – this platform is where you obtain a pre-application identification number, notify the studies you plan to include in your submission, and access pre-submission advice along with tailored information. It also offers opportunities for further engagement in later phases. You can register by following this quick guide.

Notifying studies to EFSA - before they start

Studies submitted in support of an application that were commissioned or carried out after 27/03/2021 must be notified to EFSA using the Connect.EFSA portal, before the study starts.

Request general pre-submission advice to EFSA

From the early stages of your application, we strongly recommend requesting pre-submission advice to clarify any doubts you may have regarding the requirements and content of your future application. The advice will be provided in collaboration with the RMS and co-RMS where relevant, and with the EMS for MRL The maximum amount of a pesticide residue allowed in foods or animal feeds, expressed as milligrams per kilogram applications.  

Request pre-submission advice to RMS/EMS

At any time, before submitting your application, you may request pre-submission advice to the RMS/co-RMS or to the EMS for MRL applications. The RMS/co-RMS or the EMS may provide written advice or via an online meeting and may consult EFSA in the preparation of the advice.  

2. Submission and admissibility check

  • International Uniform Chemical Information Database (IUCLID) – a software application for recording, storing, maintaining and exchanging data on intrinsic and hazard A substance or activity which has the potential to cause adverse effects to living organisms or environments properties of chemical substances, and the standard data format agreed for pesticide applications.  

You need to create a legal entity to prepare your application for submission. The application is then submitted through the submission portal. Follow the instructions in the IUCLID manuals to learn how to proceed. A training course for applicants is also available.

Follow the steps described in the administrative guidance and ensure you provide scientific information in line with the requirements described in the legislation and scientific guidance. 

Exposure assessment One of the key steps in risk assessment, this relates to a thorough evaluation of who, or what, has been exposed to a hazard and a quantification of the amounts involved tools

Estimating the chronic and acute dietary consumer exposure to pesticide residues is a necessary step for the dietary risk assessment of maximum residue levels (MRLs). We provide a tool to help you do this – the Pesticide Residue Intake Module (PRIMo) is based on national food consumption data and implements methodologies to assess the short-term (acute) and long-term (chronic) dietary consumer exposure.

When preparing an application, it is also important to assess the exposure of operators, workers, residents and bystanders to pesticides. We provide you the OPEX calculation tool in an annex to the guidance document on non-dietary exposure to pesticides. The calculator provides real-time estimates of non-dietary exposure under specific conditions for the different population Community of humans, animals or plants from the same species groups.

Harmonising the calculation of predicted environmental concentrations (PEC) of active substances is also a necessary step. For this purpose, the Forum for the co-ordination of pesticide fate models and their use (FOCUS DG SANTE) was created.

How does it work? FOCUS simulation models and scenarios help you calculate the concentrations of plant protection products in groundwater and surface water. You can obtain the currently approved versions of the models and scenarios at this link.

Hazard assessment part of a risk assessment that involves identifying and characterising potential hazards associated with biological, chemical and physical agents that may be present in food tools

When preparing your application, you will also need to calculate dermal absorption from in vitro Research method which involves testing cells or tissues extracted from living organisms studies. The guidance document on dermal absorption includes in an annex, a calculation tool available as a free download, provided by the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR).

Assessing the risk of plant protection products and bees is also a necessary step during the scientific risk assessment. To achieve this, the guidance document suggests a tiered approach A way of organising toxicology assessments to maximise efficiency and minimise the use of animals. It involves a hierarchy (tiers) of tests, starting with those that use existing information or simple biological methods before moving onto tests using cells and eventually live animals only as necessary. Annexed to the guidance, there is a calculation tool that helps you provide the necessary data for the screening step of the first tier of the process.

When preparing an application under Regulation EC 1107/2009 or Regulation EC 396/2005, you are required to provide data on metabolism The total sum of physical and chemical processes that occur within living organisms for residues and mammalian toxicology. We provide a tool to help you do this – the MetaPath composer software has been developed to collect, organise and analyse experimental data on metabolism or catabolism, observed biotransformation pathways and crucial supporting metadata. This tool allows you to build custom databases and import existing ones, such as EFSA’s public MetaPath database.

The submission process takes place entirely online. Once you have created your application and uploaded all the required information and documents, your application is ready for submission. The application is submitted to the competent authority of an EU Member State of your choice. You can consult the list of competent authorities at this link.

Before submitting your application, it is important that you follow two verification steps that will help you successfully complete your submission:

  • Run the validation assistant in IUCLID to ensure that your dossier is complete. This tool will also be used by the MS during the admissibility check so you should ensure you address any warnings that it highlights
  • Run the Dissemination preview in IUCLID and generate an advanced copy of the filtered dossier. This will enable you to cross-check that no confidential business information will be disclosed when your dossier is published

Once you’ve submitted your application, the RMS/EMS performs the admissibility check and verifies the notified studies. The RMS/EMS may contact you to request further information if anything is missing or incorrectly submitted. This may also include additional information needed in relation to confidentiality and sanitisation.

When the application is considered complete, the RMS/EMS notifies the applicant, EFSA, the Commission and the other EU Member States of the admissibility of the application.

3. Risk assessment and EFSA’s evaluation

After the application is declared admissible, the RMS/EMS assesses your application. During this phase, we hold a public consultation on the non-confidential version of your application dossier on Connect.EFSA.

If the RMS/EMS requires additional information during the risk assessment, you will have to update your IUCLID dossier. Once the RMS/EMS assessment is finalised and an Assessment Report (DAR/RAR) with the outcome of the risk assessment is drafted, this is made available to EFSA and checked for completeness. 

Together with the DAR/RAR, the RMS is strongly encouraged to submit a proposal for Harmonised Classification and Labelling (CLH) of your active substance to ECHA, to allow alignment of EFSA’s peer review and ECHA’s classification. 

In the case of a MRL application, the EMS drafts an Evaluation Report with the outcome of the exposure assessment and recommendations on the setting of MRLs, that is made available to EFSA. 

When the assessment report is considered complete, our scientists perform a peer review of the assessment report in consultation with experts from the Member States. During this phase we launch a consultation on the assessment report with the public, the applicant and the Member States.

You can monitor the progress of your application on our Open.EFSA Portal, a publicly available platform where users can follow the life cycle of all our ongoing and completed scientific activities.

During the peer review phase, our scientists may require additional information from you. If we request additional information, the clock is stopped to allow you time to provide it.

The peer review is complete when EFSA issues a conclusion which describes the outcome of the peer review process. 

EFSA in cooperation with the EMS assesses the application, performs a consumer risk assessment and determines the recommended MRLs.  

You can monitor the progress of your application on our Open.EFSA Portal.

During the assessment, our scientists may require additional information from you. If we request additional information, the clock is stopped to allow you time to provide it.  

EFSA’s assessment is complete when EFSA delivers an opinion on the risks associated with the setting, modification or deletion of an MRL.   

4. Post-adoption

What happens following adoption? Publication of EFSA’s output & regulatory decision by risk managers.

Publication follows the end of the evaluation phase but usually takes a few weeks as we carry out editorial checks and adapt the document to the scientific publishing platform used for the EFSA Journal.

Once the conclusion is issued, responsibility for your application switches from EFSA to the European Commission. The Commission, together with EU Member States, decides whether to approve/renew the approval of your active substance. In case of a MRL application, EFSA issues an opinion that is taken into consideration by the Commission and EU Member States for the MRL setting.

How to follow post-adoption

You can continue to follow your application on Open.EFSA.

If your active substance is approved, it will be included in the EU Pesticide Database. This database allows users to search for information on active substances used in plant protection products, MRLs, and emergency approvals.

Application jargon explained

When you submit an application, you will find it useful to understand the jargon used to explain certain procedural aspects. These are explained in our administrative guidance. Some common examples follow:

“Notification of study”: the process of submitting a notification of the studies which will support your application. Studies must be notified in Connect.EFSA before they are conducted.

“Additional data request”: during the evaluation, EFSA may request additional information to complete the peer review or the risk assessment.

“Clock-stop”: term used when EFSA requests additional information during the peer review phase. The deadline for delivering EFSA’s output is put on hold to give you time to submit the requested information.