Guidance for evaluating laboratory and field dissipation studies to obtain DegT50 values of plant protection products in soil

Tabs

Article
Panel on Plant Protection Products and their Residues
Acknowledgements

The Panel wishes to thank the members of the Working Group on Persistence in soil / Fate for the preparation of this opinion: Jos Boesten, Michael Klein, Richard Bromilow, Ettore Capri, Aaldrik Tiktak, Jan Vanderborght, Ton van der Linden, Elena Prados Alonso, Walter Steurbaut; the external experts Bernhard Gottesbüren, Ian Hardy, Ludovic Loiseau, Ciro Gardi and EFSA’s staff member(s) Christopher Lythgo, Olaf Mosbach-Schulz, Nicoleta Suciu and Mark Egsmose for the support provided for this EFSA scientific output.

EFSA Journal
EFSA Journal 2010;8(12):1936
doi
10.2903/j.efsa.2010.1936
Panel members at the time of adoption
Jos Boesten, Claudia Bolognesi, Theo Brock, Ettore Capri, Anthony Hardy, Andrew Hart, Karen Hirsch-Ernst, Susanne Hougaard-Bennekou, Michael Klein, Robert Luttik, Angelo Moretto, Bernadette Ossendorp, Annette Petersen, Yolanda Pico, Andreas Schäffer, Paulo Sousa, Walter Steurbaut, Anita Strömberg, Maria Tasheva, Ton van der Linden, Christiane Vleminckx
Contact
Type
Guidance of the Scientific Committee/Scientific Panel
On request from
EFSA
Question Number
EFSA-Q-2010-00931
Adopted
25 November 2010
Published
16 December 2010
Affiliation
European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), Parma, Italy
Note
Abstract

The European Commission asked the Panel to revise the Guidance Document on persistence in soil (SANCO/9188VI/1997 of 12 July 2000). Therefore the Panel started the development of a revised methodology for the assessment of exposure of soil organisms. This opinion provides guidance on how to derive the half-life for degradation in the top 30 cm of soil at reference temperature and moisture conditions (i.e. 20oC and field capacity) from the results of field studies in which the plant protection product was sprayed onto the soil surface. This half-life is an important input parameter in model simulations of the exposure of organisms in soil for annual crops under conventional and reduced tillage and therefore this guidance is an important part of this revised methodology. The Panel proposes the splitting of field dissipation studies into two parts viz. before and after at least 10 mm of rain has fallen since application. The Panel recommends evaluating field dissipation studies with models capable of considering a biphasic decline and taking only the slow phase of this decline, taken to represent degradation in the soil matrix rather than loss processes from the soil surface, into account for estimating this half-life. If however, surface processes do not seem to occur the Panel proposes to use single first-order kinetics after eliminating data points before 10 mm of rain has fallen. The Panel proposes basing the relevant population of half-lives for a certain soil exposure scenario on the assumption that a half-life measured for any non-volcanic agricultural soil from temperate regions can be used to predict the half-life for any such soil within the EU. The aim is to estimate the geomean half-life of this relevant population. The Panel considers it necessary to include the uncertainty resulting from the sample size of the population in the estimation of this geomean. If the relevant population of half-lives for a certain exposure scenario consists of a mixture of values obtained in the laboratory and in the field, the Panel recommends rejecting the laboratory values only if the null hypothesis that laboratory and field half-lives are equal is rejected. The Panel considers that this guidance will also be useful to determine half-lives to be used in scenario calculations for the assessment of leaching to groundwater and surface water. Should the notifier want to use results of field dissipation studies for estimating the half-life in the top 30 cm of soil as an input parameter for exposure models, the Panel recommends incorporating the plant protection product to a depth of about 10 cm in soil immediately after application.

Keywords
field persistence, degradation, dissipation, half-life, accumulation, exposure, soil organisms